All photographs by E. Tammy Kim

11 Allen Street: Portrait of a Chinatown Housing Struggle

A photo essay.

By E. Tammy Kim
August 10, 2012 | , , , , , , ,

Several weeks ago, I followed my friend and colleague, Shafaq Islam, a housing attorney, to a tenant meeting in Chinatown. Around 20 residents of 11 Allen Street—mostly Chinese and Malaysian immigrants—gathered at CAAAV: Organizing Asian Communities, a grassroots nonprofit on Hester Street, to hear a litigation update from Shafaq and to strategize with Esther Wang, a community organizer.

The landlord of 11 Allen Street, Fei Wang, delivered termination notices in January 2011, giving the tenants only 10 days to vacate. His reason was obvious: the building could be developed into a luxury building, with rents double or triple what the current tenants pay. When the residents refused to leave, Fei Wang instituted “holdover” (eviction) proceedings in housing court, arguing that the building was zoned for commercial use only and that the tenants had no rights under rent-stabilization or other protective laws. Represented by Shafaq and the Community Development Project at the Urban Justice Center, the tenants, some of whom have lived in the building nearly 30 years, responded that they were entitled to remain under the housing laws and that the landlord had operated in bad faith, having refused to make repairs or maintain the building in accordance with basic habitability standards.

Through the life of the housing court case, the tenants have staged protests with CAAAV and spoken out about conditions in Chinatown, while carrying on as before: working as waiters or in laundromats, sending remittances, and sharing tight, subdivided quarters—community in exchange for privacy. Shafaq recently did a walk-through to make sure they are abiding by the city’s health-and-safety codes, which cover access to fire escapes and the like. I tagged along, camera in tow, and was touched by the tenants’ openness. As Shafaq said, “My clients are so much more welcoming and generous than people who have apartments 10 times the size.”

Photographs selected from “11 Allen Street: Chinatown Residents Fighting for the Right to Remain in Their Homes,” an exhibition at the Austrian Cultural Forum.

August 13 to 19
Viewing hours: 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.
11 East 52nd Street
New York City

Wednesday, August 15, 6:30 p.m.

Sponsored by:
Austrian Cultural Forum / WochenKlausur Features
CAAAV: Organizing Asian Communities
Open City Magazine / Asian American Writers’ Workshop
Community Development Project at the Urban Justice Center

It’s a classic Chinatown tenement: tall, brick, fire-escape corset.

Chat Moi Ng lets us in.

The hallway narrows, squeezed by subdivision; each railroad-style apartment splits into several more.

Loh Hoong Sue’s door opens into light.

Certain rooms feel temporary.

Tenants busy themselves to survive the summer heat.

Community is dense at 11 Allen.

Mrs. Jiang draws back a curtain divider.

Attorney Shafaq Islam instructs tenants on fire-escape access.

Zhi Hui Liu and fellow tenants discuss litigation strategy at CAAAV.

CAAAV organizer Esther Wang displays a sign used in one of their protests. 

Helen Choong is a tenant leader. “Why do you want to stay here?” I ask. “It’s so convenient,” she says.

Anthony Lee has lived here since 1986. “Do you miss your family?” I ask. “My friends are my family,” he says. 

Some live with traditional extended family.

The tenants’ future here remains uncertain.

E. Tammy Kim covers Chinatown and the Lower East Side as Open City's Creative Nonfiction Fellow. In her free time, she scribbles tiny cartoons on beer coasters and eats lots of kale. Find more at

Tags: , , , , , , ,

If you liked this article and would like to donate to the writer and the Asian American Writers’ Workshop, please DONATE HERE.

Posted in , Reportage, Stories

  1. Pingback: Gentrification: Coming to a Neighborhood Near You « ??? Five Spice Alley

Add a comment
2500 characters allowed
User Guidelines

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


We would like to collect information during your visit to help us better understand site use. This data is anonymized, and will not be used for marketing purposes. Read More on our Privacy Policy page. You can withdraw permission at any time or update your privacy settings here. Please choose below to continue.

Show Buttons
Hide Buttons